Two more games trackers

When I originally launched this site I checked out a few of the different Games Trackers and noted my thoughts about them. I would then add to this when I came across the AllMyGames which I wrote about in November last year.

Since then I stumbled into this discussion thread on ResetEra: ‘We are getting closer to a Letterboxd for games’. This peaked my interest because also since setting up this site I have discovered Letterboxd and love logging movies I have watched in the Diary view. As well as tracking what’s coming up. Although as I’m not a serious movie fan my use case is limited.

However this led to trying out two new Game Trackers.

GG

Interestingly this advertises itself as Letterboxd for games. Like both of the game tackers mentioned here I love the visual presentation style, lots of screenshots, clean and simple design which seems to extend through to the feature set. The are some basic categories for Beaten, Completed etc. and the ability to add lists and make these public. And you can also follow your friends on the site to see what they are up to.

I do feel the site is a bit basic in what you can do at the moment. You can’t track how long you’ve played the game for, or record what format you own a game on. Also lacking an import from a platform feature so everything has to be logged manually. However a strength here is that it has its own mobile app on Android and iOS.

IGDB

Again a really nice presentation style. Kind of a cross between Twitter meets Letterboxd. Like GG mentioned above this seems quite basic at the moment in terms of the feature set but the developer seems very active and has mentioned big changes are coming for 2019. There is nowhere to log time played or other metadata. And it could do with more categories (called Activity Lists here). Although like GG has it’s own mobile apps on Android and iOS. I think the strength of this site could be discoverability of games through it’s community provided it gains an active and large enough audience.

I definitely want to keep an eye on both websites to see how they develop as they both look very promising.

I’ve also adding a short summary list of all the Game Trackers I’ve tried to my new updated Backlog page (was called Rules before).

All the games are belong to us

When I first set up the site, I tested a few different videogame tracking websites and came to the conclusion that Grouvee was the best one for me. Indeed I ended up contributing to help support the site I liked it that much. In the months since I’ve come across some more videogame trackers, such as Completionator, Darkadia and SteamCompletionist, amongst others.

However I have just recently become aware of another videogame tracker; AllMyGames (after stumbling across the reddit feed: r/AllMyGames). This new website appears to have been recently setup this year and indeed signing up to the site awarded me an ‘Early Adopter’ badge. After trying out the site I have to say I was left feeling pretty positive about it. It’s import feature works really well and is the first time I’ve seen importing of your games from anything other than Steam.  It appears to look at your achievements from your console games to build your library. Although I have a total of 1086 games (at the time of writing according to Grouvee), the import on AllMyGames managed to pick up 841 of those. That’s very impressive.

What I liked

  • Easy and fast import process from Steam, GOG, PlayStation and Xbox
  • Clean, big screen presentation style with an emphasis on cover art
  • Can select which version of the game you are adding (although l couldn’t select the digital version of Assassin’s Creed Odyssey Ultimate Edition).
  • Succinct categories; might play, won’t play etc. – I love this!
  • A icon with a relevant link to HowLongToBeat.com page for each game

Would love to see

  • Ability to add own lists
  • Sort by format, as well as platform
  • I personally hate duplicates so the option to merge duplicates games with an icon for each format the game is owned on
  • Some more metadata options such as time played, or to complete etc.

I will play around with this one more, but it’s great to see another option for videogame fans looking to list their games with regards to sorting their collection or backlog. As noted this seems to be in an early stage of development so I look forward to how this website develops.

You can check out the site yourself at the following address: All My Games.

Thoughts on games trackers

So where to begin when listing all the games you own?

It was a question I’ve had to answer when setting up this website. Lots of options like using a simple spreadsheet, or categories on Steam. However all of these have limitations. One thing I have realised is that there simply isn’t a perfect videogame tracking website. At least for me.

These are my thoughts on the websites I tested:

Backloggery.com
Probably the most well known website for tracking your videogame collection and backlog. I love the simple categorisation and presentation of whether you have beaten or unfinished a game. Has a great one page summary view that can be personalised. The ability to add notes to games or even whether a game is part of a compilation. However I don’t like the presentation style. Obviously aiming for a retro look, but I think it feels slightly dated in use.

HowLongToBeat.com
The strength of this site is it’s community data with regards to how long a game takes to playthrough. It is a very useful reference site in this regard. Nice presentation style, although one minor niggle is you can’t link games to more that one format, therefore creating duplicate entries.

Grouvee.com
Very clean presentation style and layout (Good Reads for videogames basically). Love the fact you can add notes and images to games, use tags, and record games as being owned on multiple different formats. Uses the Giantbomb database for records, so haven’t yet found a game that isn’t on the site. And even after using the site for only a few days, I’ve already observed there is a helpful community who actively comment or respond on profile updates.

Backloggery and HowLongToBeat are free, although you can make donations. Grouvee is also free, but has a $10 yearly subscription that removes adverts and rewards the user with a profile badge.

My conclusions

I decided that Grouvee best meets my needs for tracking my videogame collection backlog. With the ability to tag my games, using their ‘shelves’ system, I’ve been able to simply prioritise the games I want to play or complete the most. And the social features are the strongest of the sites I tested.

However for tracking my physical videogame collection I am still going to use Google Sheets. Simply because this can be used to store custom data such as where and when I purchased a game or hardware, where from and what condition etc. There are more collector oriented websites and programs out there but they are more than I need at the moment.